Kenwood Press


Serving the communities of Kenwood, Glen Ellen and Oakmont

email print
News: 08/01/2016

Belden Barns environmental review questioned



At a recent Board of Supervisors meeting, some residents of Sonoma Mountain Road challenged the findings and analysis of a Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) prepared for the Belden Barns winery and creamery project.

The Belden Barns development proposal, the first of its kind on Sonoma Mountain Road, is asking the county for a use permit for a facility that would process 10,000 cases of wine and 10,000 pounds of cheese. There would be public retail sales and by appointment tastings, and eight agricultural promotional events a year with 60-200 attendees.

Current structures on the property would be torn down, and 15,851 square feet of new buildings would be constructed – a production facility, tasting room, and employee housing unit.

The 55-acre property is located at 5561 Sonoma Mountain Road, about one and a half miles east of the Pressley Road/Sonoma Mountain Road intersection.

The voluminous DEIR concluded that any environmental impacts could be reduced to a “less than significant level” with the implementation of mitigation measures, a finding that speakers at the July 19 Board of Supervisors meeting took issue with.

Specifically, speakers said that no efforts could mitigate the road safety issues on Sonoma Mountain Road, a 7.5-mile, two-lane road that is narrow and windy in places, and considered one of the worst roads in Sonoma County.

In addition, some speakers questioned the hydrology analysis of the DEIR and whether it accurately represented the project’s impacts on nearby water sources.

Also discussed by the public and board was the DEIR’s analysis of alternatives to the project as proposed, including eliminating the tasting room or having it be off-site, such as in Santa Rosa or Rohnert Park. Another alternative under review is one that eliminates the events component.

Throughout the entire time since the Belden Barns first filed their use permit request in 2012, a number of neighbors have been concerned about future development in the Sonoma Mountain Road area if Belden Barns was approved. Those concerns were voiced again at the July 19 hearing.

“Please keep in mind there are 16 vineyards in the immediate area that are in line to follow the Beldens,” said Donna Parker, who lives right across from Belden Barns. “And why not? They can make more money right where they are. So the precedent setting nature of this proposal cannot be ignored.”

The hearing on the DEIR was held to receive oral comments on the document. County planners and an environmental consultant have been receiving written comments as well. The next step involves responding to all the comments and bringing a final EIR back in front of the Board of Supervisors, who at that time will consider the overall merits of the project as well, likely this Fall.

That hearing will mark the second time the Board of Supervisors has been asked to approve the Belden Barns Project. By a 4-1 vote in November of 2014, the board approved the project. First District Supervisor Susan Gorin voted against issuing the use permit.

A group of Sonoma Mountain road residents, the Friends of Sonoma Mountain, soon filed a lawsuit against the county. In June of 2015, a settlement was reached, which required that an EIR be conducted. The settlement set aside the board’s initial approval of the project and dismissed the lawsuit “with prejudice,” a legal term barring Friends of Sonoma Mountain from suing again on the same claims.

Editor & Publisher
Email: alec@kenwoodpress.com

Recently Published:

07/15/2020 - Glen Ellen Forumís busy July agenda
07/15/2020 - Fire Season 2020 top 10 tips
07/15/2020 - Political action alive and well in Oakmont...
07/15/2020 - Huffman hosts town hall on climate crisis
07/15/2020 - GE cannabis projects on SVCAC agenda
07/15/2020 - With eight COVID cases at Oakmont Gardens, OVA delays reopening gym, other facilities
07/15/2020 - New face on Planning Commission
07/15/2020 - Sonoma Valley Fire District is now official
07/15/2020 - Itís official: The Jim Berkland Bridge!
07/15/2020 - North Valley Municipal Advisory Council appointed
07/15/2020 - Homeless shelter to stay untilÖ ?
07/15/2020 - New project manager steps into SDC Specific Plan process
07/15/2020 - New face on Planning Commission
07/15/2020 - Four Kenwood Fire District director seats up for election
07/15/2020 - Food bank distributes in Kenwood, Glen Ellen
07/15/2020 - New Sonoma County report on use of services
07/01/2020 - Fire preparedness virtual town hall meeting July 10
07/01/2020 - Supervisor Gorin selects members of North Valley MAC
07/01/2020 - All outdoor burning banned
07/01/2020 - Your Majesties
07/01/2020 - County, local fire departments begin inspecting for hazards
07/01/2020 - Kenwood Press resumes regular publication schedule
07/01/2020 - Fire safe resources
07/01/2020 - Vegetation compliance webinar
07/01/2020 - First Virtual Book Club

Community Calendar

Virtual Book Club
07/15/2020
more...
Cal Alumni Club dinner
07/16/2020
more...
Sonoma Valley groundwater community workshop
07/20/2020
more...